Who Has More Car Accidents - Male or Female Drivers?

    As a personal injury attorney representing victims of car accidents for over 20 years, I'm often asked if men or women have more accidents behind the wheel. This is an important question, as understanding accident trends can help make our roads safer. After reviewing the data and my own case files, I've concluded that men are more likely to be involved in car crashes than women. However, there are important nuances to this issue that deserve further discussion.

    Looking At The Data

    First, let's look at the statistics. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), around 70% of drivers involved in fatal crashes are men. Furthermore, research shows that men have a higher rate of serious infractions like DUIs, speeding, and reckless driving. These behaviors clearly contribute to a higher accident risk.

    Does this mean all male drivers are inherently more dangerous? Absolutely not. We must avoid dangerous stereotypes. However, the data indicates certain driving behaviors more prevalent among men do elevate their risk profile. As attorneys advocating for accident victims, we must go where the facts lead us, even if they are inconvenient or politically incorrect.

    Now, it's also true that men simply drive more miles than women on average. It goes without saying that exposure and time on the road contribute greatly to accident risk. So in my view, the higher mileage accounts for a portion of men's higher crash rate, but not all of it. The data on traffic violations and aggressive driving suggests men tend to engage in riskier driving habits overall.

    So What Does This Mean?

    I never want to paint any group with too broad a brush. Not all male drivers are hazardous, just like not all female drivers are safe. Individual driving ability varies enormously across genders. We must judge each accident on its own facts.

    At the same time, the data doesn't lie. Male drivers have a measurably higher incidence of crashes. As attorneys and safety advocates, we can't ignore that reality. We need to have an open conversation about the driving behaviors and cultural attitudes that may contribute to this discrepancy.

    For instance, traditional gender norms often depict men as strong risk-takers, who value aggression, speed, and competition. While positive in moderation, these traits can be dangerous when driving a 4,000 pound vehicle. Perhaps we need more nuanced male role models who embrace caution and patience on the road.

    I also firmly believe driver education should emphasize crash avoidance and de-escalation for all new drivers regardless of gender. My job involves picking up the pieces after accidents every day. I constantly see the pain and devastation bad driving choices cause. Every driver needs to approach operating a vehicle with the utmost care and focus, like a pilot flying a plane. Lives are at stake.

    In my practice, I've also seen that male drivers under 25 have a higher accident and traffic offense rate. This dangerous combination of youth and aggression on the road results in many needless tragedies. I believe licensing requirements and driver education should focus especially on mentoring young men to make smart choices behind the wheel during this high-risk period. Early intervention could save countless lives.

    On the other side of the equation, female drivers have lower crash rates overall. However, the data also reveals some notable trends. For instance, while men have more frequent minor accidents, women statistically cause more major crashes involving serious injuries and higher fatality rates.

    This could be due to factors like lower seatbelt use or driving smaller, lighter cars that offer less protection. Additionally, while women generally drive less, they have a higher accident rate per mile driven. As attorneys, we need to take a nuanced view of gender and driver safety. Simply chalking crashes up to intrinsic traits does little to keep people safe. We need to look deeper at the cultural and educational factors that shape driving behavior across genders. Only then can we work to improve safety for all motorists.

    I also believe strongly in personalized justice. Every car accident has unique facts and drivers with individual strengths and weaknesses. While data trends can inform our overall traffic safety efforts, I treat each client as an individual. If a negligent driver causes harm, they should be held accountable regardless of age or gender.

    At the same time, no driver, male or female, is inherently "safe" or "dangerous." Individual conduct and choices make all the difference. With education, mentoring, and heightened personal awareness, all motorists can develop caution, patience and focus behind the wheel. As a society, we must foster a culture of safe driving, free of harmful stereotypes.

    On the policy level, graduated licensing, well-enforced traffic laws, and robust driver education will also help address high-risk behaviors. As attorneys advocating for those injured in crashes, we support thoughtful reforms rooted in data, not assumptions. Our goal is to promote safety and justice for all who share the roads.

    While certain alarming crash trends currently skew toward male drivers, early intervention and a culture shift could greatly improve safety. No one is beyond hope, and past mistakes must not be used to justify apathy or cynicism. Together, through compassion and commitment to the facts, we can create a future of smarter, safer driving. That is my mission as an attorney, and one I know many motorists share. There is always room for positive change when lives are on the line.

    Illinois Specific Data

    Illinois-specific data from 2022-2023 affirms the nationwide trends of men causing more auto accidents than women. According to the Illinois Department of Transportation, around 70% of fatal crashes in the state involve male drivers. Additionally, a full 80% of reckless driving citations in Illinois are issued to men. These statistics mirror the national data showing men tend to engage in riskier driving behaviors.

    Specifically in Illinois, men received over 450,000 traffic citations in 2022 compared to just under 300,000 for women. Men also accounted for 75% of drunk driving arrests, 70% of speeding tickets, and 65% of distracted driving infractions statewide last year. This aligns with research demonstrating that violations like impaired driving, not obeying the speed limit, and phone use while driving elevate accident risk significantly.

    Illinois' crash data for 2022 also reveals that the highest accident rate occurs among young men under 25. This demographic received 30% of all citations last year, despite making up just 10% of licensed state drivers. Clearly, interventions are needed to target reckless driving among young male motorists.

    For female drivers in Illinois, the data shows lower violation rates overall. However, among serious crashes in 2022, women had a higher incidence of speeding, DUI, and distracted driving citations. This suggests that while most female drivers make safer choices, those who do offend engage are more likely to engage in reckless conduct behind the wheel.

    Insurance companies take these statewide trends into account when setting rates. In Illinois, companies are allowed to consider gender when determining premiums. According to the most recent filings, insurance providers in Illinois generally charge young men the highest premiums based on elevated risk. For example, Nationwide insures an 18-year-old male driver for around $4,500 annually on average versus just $3,200 for a female of the same age. However, according to a recent article released by The Zebra and backed by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, seven states now ban gender as a rating factor in car insurance.

    It is important to recognize to note that the gap in premium prices between men and women drivers narrows significantly after the high-risk 16-25 age range. This aligns with the crash data showing women overall have lower violation rates, while young male driving poses particular concerns. Companies also consider factors like vehicle type, mileage, and zip code alongside gender to customize premiums.

    So in summary, current figures from Illinois affirm that male drivers, especially young ones, have measurably higher accident and offense rates. The insurance industry responds to these trends by pricing youthful male driver policies higher. However, gender is just one risk factor among many evaluated. No demographic can be completely generalized. In my practice, I focus on individual driver behaviors and choices that lead to crashes. That holds true whether representing injured male or female clients in Illinois.

    The Importance of Working With an Experienced Attorney

    Being in a crash can be a terrifying, chaotic experience. Your life and plans can be upended in an instant due to another driver's negligence. The legal process afterward often only adds frustration and uncertainty. This is where having a seasoned personal injury attorney on your side can make all the difference.

    An established Illinois accident lawyer has the expertise to handle your property damage claim, medical bills, lost income, and long-term rehabilitation costs. We intricately understand auto insurance laws and claims processes in this state. Our teams can conduct thorough crash investigations, preserve evidence, and build an airtight liability case against the at-fault driver.

    Equally important, we have the negotiating leverage from years of settlements to get you maximum compensation. Auto insurers know we won't hesitate to take a strong case to trial if needed. This brings them to the table with higher offers. In contrast, going it alone against their team of attorneys is daunting, if not impossible, for injury victims.

    Additionally, an experienced attorney understands the full scope of damages you may be entitled to. Beyond just immediate medical bills, crashes can cause lost income from missed work, permanent disabilities, physical and emotional pain/suffering, property loss, and other costs. We fight to recover compensation for all of it. No victim should be left footing the bills.

    The contingency fee model used by most Illinois personal injury firms also means you pay nothing upfront. Our fees come only from a percentage of your final settlement. This ensures top legal advocates are affordable for all crash victims.

    Moving Forward

    In the realm of vehicle accidents, it's important to recognize that numerous factors come into play, and it's not fair to attribute risky driving behavior to gender alone. Age group is one significant determinant in understanding driver behavior, as younger drivers are often considered more at risk due to their relative inexperience behind the wheel. However, it's crucial to avoid blanket assumptions based on gender differences when it comes to accidents. The influence of alcohol, for instance, can be a significant contributing factor in collisions, leading to more car accidents regardless of gender. Ultimately, it's essential to consider the diverse range of factors  that impact road safety and avoid making sweeping judgments based solely on gender.

    A knowledgeable local attorney simply provides peace of mind during what is inevitably a very stressful process. You can focus on healing while we handle negotiations, court appearances, paperwork, and communication with insurers and investigators. Our guidance and counsel take the burden off your shoulders.

    A seasoned personal injury lawyer levels the playing field against big auto insurers and at-fault drivers. We tip the scales back to you receiving full and fair compensation. Don't go it alone and risk getting lowballed. With an experienced Illinois accident attorney, you can be made whole again.

    At Palermo Law Group, our goal is to do just that. The car accident lawyers at our law firm are here to help. Call now for a free consultation at (630)684-2332, or visit our website at


    Mario Palermo is the Founder and Lead Attorney at Palermo Law Group in Oak Brook, Illinois. For the past 26 years, he has worked tirelessly to help injury victims and their families in their times of need. He is a seasoned authority on civil litigation, and also a member of the Million Dollar Advocates Forum, a prestigious group of trial lawyers who have won million and multi-million dollar verdicts and settlements. Mr. Palermo has been named a “Leading Lawyer” by his peers in 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021 and 2022.

    Request a Free Legal Consultation

    Recently Published

    Recent Outcomes

    $1.3 Million

    Mr. Palermo obtained $1.3 million dollars for an airline employee who was injured on the job.


    Palermo obtained $800,000 for the family of 63-year-old woman who died after gallbladder removal surgery.


    Palermo obtained $400,000 for a 28-year-old woman from Aurora that was the victim of a hit-and-run.