How to Recognize Signs of Involuntary Seclusion Abuse in Nursing Homes


    As an Illinois plaintiff’s personal injury attorney deeply invested in advocating for the rights and well-being of the elderly, I find it imperative to address a form of abuse that often goes unnoticed within nursing home settings: involuntary seclusion. Involuntary seclusion occurs when a resident is isolated from others against their will, not for the resident's own safety or health but as a means of punishment or convenience for the staff. This form of abuse can have profound psychological and physical effects on residents, making it crucial to recognize its signs and take action.

    What Is Involuntary Seclusion?

    Involuntary seclusion is a form of nursing home abuse that involves the separation of a resident from social activities and interactions, as well as restricting their freedom of movement within the facility. This can occur through physical confinement, such as locking a resident in a room or restricting them to a specific area of the facility. Alternatively, it may involve socially isolating the resident, depriving them of meaningful interactions with caregivers, family members, and other residents. Such practices not only violate the resident's will but can also exacerbate medical symptoms and lead to feelings of loneliness and helplessness. It's crucial for caregivers and family members to be vigilant and advocate for the resident's rights, ensuring that care plans prioritize de-escalation techniques over the use of restraint and chemical restraint, and promote the resident's overall well-being and quality of life.

    Warning Signs of Involuntary Seclusion Abuse

    1. Sudden Changes in Behavior: A once social and active resident becoming withdrawn or showing signs of depression could indicate involuntary seclusion.   
    2. Physical Deterioration: Unexplained weight loss, poor personal hygiene, or the development of pressure sores or rashes from prolonged bed rest could signal that a resident is being confined against their will.
    3. Emotional Distress: Increased anxiety, fearfulness, especially around certain staff members, or expressions of feeling trapped or abandoned may be cries for help.
    4. Limited Access: If staff frequently prevent or discourage visits, or if there are unexplained restrictions on the resident's movement within the facility, this could be a cause for concern.

    Real-Life Examples of Involuntary Seclusion Abuse

    Case Study 1: The Forgotten Resident

    In a distressing case in Illinois, Mrs. Johnson, an 80-year-old resident with mild dementia, was found locked in a storage room. Initially explained as a safety measure during a facility-wide event, further investigation revealed that Mrs. Johnson had been isolated for several hours over multiple days, often missing meals and medications. The legal action that followed brought to light the systemic use of involuntary seclusion as a means of managing "troublesome" residents, leading to significant reforms within the facility.

    Case Study 2: The Punished Patient

    Mr. Thompson, a 75-year-old with mobility issues, was frequently left alone in his room, with his walker placed just out of reach. Staff justified this as necessary for his safety, claiming he was prone to falls. However, it became apparent that this was a punitive measure for Mr. Thompson's complaints about the facility. Legal intervention ensured Mr. Thompson was transferred to a more supportive environment, and the facility faced consequences for their abusive practices.

    What to Do If You Suspect Involuntary Seclusion Abuse

    1. Document Your Observations: Keep detailed notes of any signs of abuse, including dates, times, and descriptions of the resident's physical and emotional state.   
    2. Speak Up: Express your concerns to the facility's management. If the response is inadequate or dismissive, escalate the matter.
    3. Seek Legal Counsel: Contact a personal injury attorney experienced in elder abuse cases. They can provide guidance on how to protect your loved one and potentially hold the facility accountable.
    4. Report the Abuse: File a report with the Illinois Department of Public Health or the local Adult Protective Services. These agencies can investigate and take action against the facility if necessary.  Reporting abuse in nursing homes, including cases of involuntary seclusion, is a critical step in protecting the rights and well-being of elderly residents. In Illinois, two key agencies are instrumental in addressing such issues: the Illinois Department of Public Health (IDPH) and the local Adult Protective Services (APS). Here's a detailed overview of how these agencies can help and the process of filing a report:

    Illinois Department of Public Health (IDPH)

    The IDPH is responsible for regulating nursing homes and ensuring they comply with state and federal standards for resident care. They have the authority to investigate complaints and take enforcement action against facilities found in violation.

    How to Report:

    - Online Reporting: The IDPH provides an online complaint form on their official website, which can be used to report abuse or neglect, including involuntary seclusion.

    - Telephone: You can also file a complaint by calling the IDPH's 24-hour Nursing Home Complaint Hotline. The hotline is staffed by healthcare professionals who can provide guidance and record your complaint.

    - Mail or Fax: Complaints can be submitted in writing via mail or fax. It's recommended to provide as much detail as possible, including the names of the individuals involved, dates, and a description of the incidents.

    What Happens After a Report is Filed:

    - Investigation: The IDPH will initiate an investigation into the reported abuse. This may involve visiting the nursing home, interviewing staff and residents, and reviewing the facility's records.

    - Findings: Upon completion of the investigation, the IDPH will issue a report detailing their findings. If violations are found, the report will outline the necessary corrective actions and any penalties imposed on the facility.

    - Follow-Up: The IDPH will monitor the facility to ensure compliance with the corrective actions. Repeat violations can lead to increased penalties, including fines and potential revocation of the facility's license.

    Adult Protective Services (APS)

    APS is dedicated to protecting vulnerable adults from abuse, neglect, and exploitation. They work closely with local law enforcement and social services to investigate complaints and provide assistance to victims.

    How to Report:

    - Local APS Office: Reports can be made directly to the local APS office serving the area where the nursing home is located. Contact information for local offices is available on the Illinois Department on Aging website.

    - APS Hotline: Illinois also has a statewide APS hotline that accepts reports of elder abuse, including involuntary seclusion in nursing homes.

    What Happens After a Report is Filed:

    - Investigation: APS will conduct a thorough investigation, which may include interviews with the victim, witnesses, and nursing home staff, as well as a review of relevant documents.

    - Assessment: APS will assess the victim's needs and determine the appropriate interventions, which may include medical care, legal intervention, or relocation to a safer environment.

    - Coordination with Other Agencies: APS may coordinate with other agencies, including the IDPH and law enforcement, to ensure a comprehensive response to the abuse.

    Key Considerations When Reporting Abuse

    - Documentation: Providing detailed information and documentation when filing a report can significantly aid the investigation. This includes dates, times, names of individuals involved, and any evidence of the abuse.

    - Confidentiality: Reports to both IDPH and APS can be made anonymously if desired. However, providing your contact information can be helpful if the investigators need additional information.

    - Legal Advice: Consulting with a personal injury attorney experienced in elder abuse cases can provide additional guidance on reporting the abuse and protecting the victim's rights.

    Reporting abuse to the IDPH and APS is a vital step in addressing involuntary seclusion and other forms of mistreatment in nursing homes. These agencies play a crucial role in investigating allegations, holding facilities accountable, and ensuring the safety and dignity of all residents.

    Hiring a Lawyer for Involuntary Seclusion Abuse in Nursing Homes

    Involuntary seclusion is a form of abuse that can significantly impact the health and dignity of nursing home residents. Recognizing the signs and taking prompt action can help protect some of our most vulnerable citizens from harm. As an advocate for the rights of the elderly, I am committed to fighting against such abuses and ensuring that victims and their families receive the justice and support they deserve. If you or a loved one have experienced involuntary seclusion in a nursing home setting, do not hesitate to reach out for legal assistance. Together, we can work to safeguard the well-being and rights of nursing home residents across Illinois.

    Hiring a personal injury attorney on a contingency basis is a common and accessible approach for many individuals seeking legal representation in personal injury cases, including those involving involuntary seclusion abuse in nursing homes. This arrangement aligns the interests of both the client and the attorney, as the attorney's payment is directly tied to the successful resolution of the case. Here's a more in-depth explanation of the process and what it entails:

    Understanding Contingency Fees

    - Percentage-Based Payment: Under a contingency fee agreement, the attorney's fees are a predetermined percentage of the settlement or court award obtained in the client's favor. This percentage is agreed upon before the attorney begins working on the case and is typically between 33% and 40%, depending on the complexity of the case and the stage at which the case is resolved.

    - No Win, No Fee: The fundamental principle of a contingency fee arrangement is that the attorney will not receive any payment for their services unless they successfully secure compensation for their client. This means if the case is not won, the client does not owe the attorney any fees for the time spent on the case.

    Advantages of Contingency Fee Arrangements

    - Accessibility: Contingency fee arrangements make legal services accessible to individuals who might not afford to pay an attorney by the hour. This opens the door for many to pursue justice without the barrier of high upfront costs.

    - Aligned Interests: Since the attorney's payment depends on the case's outcome, they are highly motivated to achieve the best possible result for their client. This alignment of interests ensures that the attorney is fully invested in the case.

    - Risk Mitigation: Clients are protected from the financial risk associated with losing the case. Since they don't pay unless they win, they're not left with large legal bills on top of their existing burdens.

    Components of the Contingency Fee Agreement

    When entering into a contingency fee arrangement, the agreement should clearly outline several important components:

    - Fee Percentage: The exact percentage of the settlement or award that will go to the attorney as fees.

    - Case Expenses: In addition to attorney fees, personal injury cases can incur various expenses, such as court filing fees, costs for obtaining medical records, expert witness fees, and costs related to investigations. The agreement should specify whether these expenses are deducted from the settlement before or after calculating the attorney's fee, and who is responsible for these costs if the case is not successful.

    - Scope of Representation: The agreement should clearly define the scope of the attorney's representation, including what aspects of the case they will handle and any limitations to their responsibilities.

    - Termination of Representation: Terms under which either party can terminate the agreement should be included, along with any financial obligations that may arise from early termination.

    The Process and What to Expect

    - Initial Consultation: This is the first step where you meet with the attorney to discuss your case. It's typically free and used to determine the viability of your case.

    - Investigation and Case Building: The attorney will gather evidence, consult with experts, and build a strong legal argument for your claim.

    - Negotiations: The attorney will attempt to negotiate a fair settlement with the opposing party or their insurance company.

    - Litigation: If negotiations don't result in a satisfactory settlement, the attorney will file a lawsuit and represent you in court.

    - Resolution: The case will be resolved either through a court verdict or a negotiated settlement. The attorney will then ensure that the settlement is collected and distributed appropriately.

    Hiring a personal injury attorney on a contingency basis can offer a practical solution for individuals seeking to hold responsible parties accountable without the upfront financial burden typically associated with legal representation. It's crucial to thoroughly understand the terms of the contingency fee agreement and to select an attorney who is transparent about the process and motivated to achieve the best outcome for your case.

    Working With Palermo Law Group

    If you suspect that you or a loved one has been a victim of involuntary seclusion in a nursing home, it's crucial to seek legal guidance and support. Working with a reputable legal representative, such as a personal injury lawyer from Palermo Law, can provide you with the expertise and advocacy needed to pursue justice and hold the responsible parties accountable. Palermo Law offers a free consultation to discuss your case and evaluate your legal options. Our compassionate team understands the complexities of nursing home abuse cases and is dedicated to fighting for the rights of victims of involuntary seclusion. Contact us today to schedule your consultation and take the first step towards seeking justice and ensuring the safety and well-being of your loved one.

    For a free consultation contact our law firm by calling (630) 684-2332 or visit our website at


    Mario Palermo is the Founder and Lead Attorney at Palermo Law Group in Oak Brook, Illinois. For the past 26 years, he has worked tirelessly to help injury victims and their families in their times of need. He is a seasoned authority on civil litigation, and also a member of the Million Dollar Advocates Forum, a prestigious group of trial lawyers who have won million and multi-million dollar verdicts and settlements. Mr. Palermo has been named a “Leading Lawyer” by his peers in 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021 and 2022.

    Request a Free Legal Consultation

    Recently Published

    Recent Outcomes

    $1.3 Million

    Mr. Palermo obtained $1.3 million dollars for an airline employee who was injured on the job.


    Palermo obtained $800,000 for the family of 63-year-old woman who died after gallbladder removal surgery.


    Palermo obtained $400,000 for a 28-year-old woman from Aurora that was the victim of a hit-and-run.